Beneath the serene waters of Lake Ontario lie two of the most remarkably preserved shipwrecks in maritime history—the USS Hamilton and USS Scourge. Once formidable naval vessels, these ships met a tragic fate on the stormy night of August 8, 1813, during the War of 1812. Their watery graves, discovered over 160 years later, have since become a treasure trove for archaeologists, offering unparalleled insights into naval history and underwater preservation.
The Tragic Sinking of Hamilton and Scourge
The War of 1812 saw intense naval battles across the Great Lakes, with Lake Ontario serving as a critical front. Originally merchant vessels, Hamilton and Scourge were repurposed as warships for the United States Navy. Armed with heavy cannons, these schooners were top-heavy and unstable—a fatal flaw that would seal their fate.
On the fateful night of August 8, 1813, a sudden squall swept across the lake. The two ships, ill-equipped to handle such weather, capsized and sank within minutes, taking 53 sailors to their deaths. The rapid sinking left no time for rescue, turning the calm waters of Lake Ontario into a haunting scene of tragedy.
Video:
Discovery of the Shipwrecks
The wrecks of Hamilton and Scourge remained undisturbed for over a century until 1973, when Dr. Daniel Nelson, a dentist and amateur archaeologist from St. Catharines, Ontario, located them. Confirmed in 1975, the discovery revealed the ships resting upright and astonishingly intact 88 meters below the lake’s surface.
What sets these shipwrecks apart is their state of preservation. Unlike typical wrecks from this era—often reduced to fragments of wood—the Hamilton and Scourge still boast intact decks, cannons, and even crossed cutlasses.
The figureheads of the ships are particularly striking: Hamilton features Diana, the Roman goddess of the hunt, while Scourge bears the likeness of Britain’s Admiral Nelson, reflecting their origins as merchant vessels before their capture and conversion into warships.
Challenges in Preservation
Despite their remarkable condition, the wrecks face significant threats, primarily from quagga mussels, an invasive species introduced to the Great Lakes by foreign ships. These mussels have colonized the lakebed and the wrecks themselves, obscuring details of the ships’ hulls and artifacts. Over time, they could encrust and conceal the wrecks entirely, complicating future archaeological efforts.
Lake Ontario’s cold, dark, and murky waters also present challenges. While these conditions have slowed decay, they make exploration and documentation difficult. Archaeologists rely on advanced technologies, such as side-scan sonar and magnetometers, to map and study the wrecks without disturbing them.
Archaeological Expeditions and Research
The discovery of Hamilton and Scourge has drawn the attention of some of the most renowned names in marine archaeology, including Jacques Cousteau (1980) and Robert Ballard (1990). Each expedition has added to the growing body of knowledge about these ships.
The 1982 expedition led by Emory Kristof was particularly groundbreaking. Using cutting-edge photography equipment, the team captured over 2,000 high-quality images of the wrecks, documenting their condition in extraordinary detail. These photographs remain invaluable, especially as the quagga mussels continue to obscure the ships’ features. Modern expeditions, such as those by Parks Canada, have employed sonar imaging to map the wrecks and gather new data.
The Human Stories Behind the Wrecks
Among the stories associated with these shipwrecks, that of Ned Myers stands out. A sailor aboard the Scourge, Myers survived the sinking and later recounted his harrowing experience. His accounts provide a poignant glimpse into the human cost of naval warfare during the War of 1812.
The ships themselves also serve as silent witnesses to history. Their artifacts, from cannons to figureheads, tell stories of life aboard naval vessels, the ingenuity of shipbuilding, and the perils faced by sailors during wartime.
Future Prospects and Conservation
The Hamilton and Scourge have been designated as National Historic Sites of Canada, protected under strict regulations that prohibit unauthorized diving. Monitoring systems ensure their preservation, and ongoing collaborations between the City of Hamilton and organizations like Parks Canada aim to safeguard their legacy.
However, the question of whether to recover artifacts or leave the wrecks undisturbed remains contentious. Raising the ships, as was done with Sweden’s Vasa or England’s Mary Rose, is not feasible due to the extensive damage quagga mussels have caused. Instead, there is growing interest in constructing life-sized replicas to educate the public about these historic vessels.
Conclusion
The USS Hamilton and USS Scourge are more than just shipwrecks; they are time capsules preserving a moment of history frozen beneath Lake Ontario’s depths. Their story is one of tragedy, resilience, and the enduring importance of preserving our shared heritage. As efforts to protect these underwater treasures continue, they remain a testament to the sacrifices of sailors and the rich history of naval warfare during the War of 1812. These ghost ships, shrouded in mystery and history, invite us to explore and reflect on the past while inspiring future generations to uncover the secrets of the deep.
